Company research
Gujarat Energy at ₹216: a fair price for earnings that are not growing
Published · Research dated
Executive summary
Not investable now at ₹216.18 (NSE close, 6 November 2026), judged over three years to November 2029 against a 15% a year required return. At 10 times FY26 earnings, the price pays for today's ₹21.5 of earnings a share to hold flat, and no more. Our five scenarios, weighted, give a value of ₹267 a share in 2029 with dividends: about 7.3% a year, most of it from a cash-returned scenario added on 8 November (1.6% a year without it). The base case returns 4.1%; the two squeeze cases, weighted 0.30, end at ₹108–139. Only two scenarios clear 15%, and both need a higher multiple as well as better news: cheap LNG winning back the Morbi ceramic cluster's gas demand, at 12 times earnings; or the company paying out its cash (about ₹71 a share) while the city-gas margin recovers and the shares re-rate to city-gas peers' 15 times. Neither is yet a fact.
Research dated 8 November 2026, on prices of 6 November 2026, mainly from the company's annual reports, investor presentations and earnings-call transcripts through the November 2026 presentation. The September-quarter results statement had not been read, and its call transcript was not yet filed. The scenario weights are our judgment; no base rate stands behind them. 15% a year is our required return for a company of this size and quality; the verdict is the same at 12% or 17.5%. The three years cover the first deliveries under new long-term LNG contracts from 2028, the LNG glut management expects in 2027–29, and the state's decision on the cash. This is personal research, not a recommendation to buy or sell.
After the merger that took effect on 1 May 2026, a Gujarat Energy share is a claim on four things:
- a city-gas distributor, the old Gujarat Gas;
- GSPC's gas-trading book, which made about 40% of segment profit;
- a loss-making LNG terminal and two gas power plants;
- about ₹7,500 crore of cash at 30 September 2026: ₹80 a share, or ₹71 if the ₹835 crore FY26 dividend was paid after that date.
Gas transmission went to a separate listed company, GSPL Transmission. A buyer today does not get those shares.
The state controls the company: the Governor of Gujarat holds 38.80%, and state undertakings about another 17%.
GSPC, GSPL and GSPC Energy were amalgamated into Gujarat Gas (appointed date 1 April 2024). Gas transmission was then demerged into GSPL Transmission (appointed date 1 April 2025). The scheme took effect on 1 May 2026, and the company was renamed Gujarat Energy on 14 May 2026.
- The 37,28,73,995 Gujarat Gas shares that GSPL held were cancelled, and 62,27,14,719 new shares were issued, for a total of 93,82,30,849.
- Two-thirds of today's shares (66.4%) went to former GSPC and GSPL holders. Old Gujarat Gas holders outside GSPL now own 33.6%.
- Holders on 2 July 2026 received one GSPL Transmission share for every three shares. At GSPL Transmission's 6 November close of ₹106.72, that entitlement was worth ₹35.57 a Gujarat Energy share. Older price histories that span the demerger may not be adjusted for it, so we do not use them.
The parent has no loans. The group's ₹3,060 crore of borrowings sit in subsidiaries, mainly the LNG terminal company; we found no parent guarantee disclosed.
City gas earned ₹2,021 crore in FY25 and ₹1,956 crore in FY26, while volume rose. Its margin fell from ₹6.73 per standard cubic metre (scm) in the June 2025 quarter to ₹4.70 in the September 2026 quarter, below management's ₹5.5–6.5 band in both quarters since the merger took effect.
In the September 2026 quarter the business sold 2.06 million scm a day more than a year earlier and earned ₹11 crore less. Management attributes the lower margin to mix: a "bigger volume now to be divided". We read the extra volume as earning almost nothing; the bearish reading is that the base margin is being squeezed.
Capex of about ₹1,000 crore a year buys pipelines and new CNG stations, but city-gas earnings have not risen with it since FY25.
| Quarter | City-gas EBITDA | ₹ per scm |
|---|---|---|
| June 2025 (Q1 FY26) | ₹544 crore | 6.73 |
| September 2025 (Q2 FY26) | ₹474 crore | 5.96 |
| December 2025 (Q3 FY26) | ₹473 crore | 6.14 |
| March 2026 (Q4 FY26) | ₹465 crore | 5.82 |
| June 2026 (Q1 FY27) | ₹582 crore | 5.18 |
| September 2026 (Q2 FY27) | ₹463 crore | 4.70 |
The June 2025 figure is management's approximate figure from the call; December 2025 is the residual of the audited FY26 total; the per-scm margins are our division of segment EBITDA by volume. In August 2026 management said, of the band, "We'll still stick to that guidance". The November 2026 presentation does not restate it.
Management's own forecasts have a mixed record. The FY26 band was 4.5–5.5 in 2025 and raised to 5.5–6.5 in January 2026; the year came in at about 6.2. Its forecasts of ceramic-cluster volume missed twice.
About a third of city-gas volume is CNG, which grew 10.6% year on year in the September 2026 quarter. Much of the industrial volume swings with the price of gas against propane, because the ceramic plants at Morbi buy on one-month contracts and switch fuel.
Their gas use went from about 0.4 million scm a day in April 2026 to about 8 in May and June, then back to about 3 after July as propane returned. In August, gas cost them about ₹78 per scm against about ₹65 for propane. Management puts the cluster's floor at 1.8–2 million scm a day, and is planning its own propane import terminal, which suggests it expects propane to stay.
This volume is priced against propane and supplied with spot LNG. In the September 2026 quarter it lifted volume but not profit; we read that, from one quarter, as the swing volume earning a thin spread.
One figure fits neither reading: industrial volume of 6.05 million scm a day in that quarter, against the 5.0–5.2 that management's own Morbi and non-Morbi figures imply.
- Cheap domestic gas keeps shrinking. The government cut its allocation of administered-price (APM) gas to city gas in October 2024 and April 2025; after the second cut it was reported to meet about 34% of city-gas needs, down from 51%. In the September 2026 quarter APM gas was 10% of the company's total sourcing and imports 55%. No cut specific to this company is established, and the size of the effect on it is not known.
- The alternative fuel caps the price. Industrial gas is priced against propane, CNG against petrol and diesel. When spot LNG is expensive, the margin gives way.
- Competition is opening, slowly. In January 2025 the regulator, PNGRB, issued a notice on declaring 71 city-gas networks common or contract carriers, 19 of them the company's; the FY26 annual report gives no outcome. Marketing exclusivity is reported to have expired in many areas. The effect is years away and its size unknown.
At least one broker took this side in August 2026, expecting Morbi volumes to fall back as propane supply eased.
The trading book buys gas, much of it imported LNG, and sells it to the city-gas business, fertiliser plants and other buyers. It made ₹3,264 crore in FY23, and ₹731 crore in the June 2026 quarter alone, during the Hormuz crisis. By the September quarter it was back to ₹330 crore: ₹2.91 per scm sourced, against ₹2.87 in FY26 once one-offs are removed.
Management guides to "around INR1,100 crores" a year, and elsewhere "INR1,100 crores to INR1,200 crores", a figure it does not define, at a margin of about 4–5%.
Together, city gas and trading earned ₹793 crore in the September 2026 quarter: 22% more than a year earlier and about 5% above FY26's recurring quarter of about ₹756 crore. The fall from the June quarter's ₹1,313 crore is the windfall unwinding, so the quarter was not a break. The contrary reading is that it still carried some crisis pricing: trading revenue was up 84% on a year earlier.
The split of profit between trading and city gas is set by an internal transfer price ("Internally, we have the flexibility of changing it"), so the combined figure is the one to forecast. Because trading's per-scm margin is back at its FY26 level, the fall in the city-gas margin does not look like profit moved into trading. That is our reading.
| Year | Trading EBITDA | Margin |
|---|---|---|
| FY22 | ₹1,623 crore | 6.7% |
| FY23 | ₹3,264 crore | 11.8% |
| FY24 | ₹1,127 crore | 6.1% |
| FY25 | ₹1,244 crore | 6.2% |
| FY26 | ₹1,335 crore | 8.3% |
FY22–FY26 are on GSPC's standalone accounts, as the company presents them. Per scm sourced (our division): ₹2.78 in the June 2025 quarter, ₹6.57 in the June 2026 crisis quarter, ₹2.91 in the September 2026 quarter.
In the standalone accounts FY26 trading was ₹1,335 crore; in the consolidated accounts, ₹1,104 crore. Our reading, not established, is that the standalone figure includes about ₹216 crore of take-or-pay income from the group's own LNG terminal, eliminated on consolidation, which would explain 94% of the gap; about ₹50 crore of customs refund is a further one-off.
New long-term LNG supply starts in 2028: 0.4 million tonnes a year from ADNOC for ten years, linked to Henry Hub, with the price formula undisclosed; the board approved 0.8 million tonnes a year in all. Management expected an LNG glut "over the next 2- 3 years" (January 2026) and prices "reasonable starting '28, '29" (June 2026). In January 2026 it expected spot LNG to come back to about $9; the Hormuz crisis overtook that.
A flat share price in November 2029 needs FY29 earnings of ₹21.62 a share at today's 10 times. That is FY26's ₹21.55, and also the latest quarter's run-rate of ₹5.31 a quarter, or ₹21.24 a year. The price is 1.06 times book value for a return on equity of about 11%; for that return against a 12% cost of equity, 8–10 times earnings is about right.
| P/E in 2029 | FY29 EPS needed for a flat price |
|---|---|
| 12x | ₹18.02 |
| 10x | ₹21.62 |
| 8x | ₹27.02 |
Our base case holds the run-rate: ₹21.54 of FY29 earnings a share at 10 times is ₹215 in 2029, plus ₹28.90 of dividends, 4.10% a year. That counts the cash the business keeps before 2029 only through its interest. Kept rather than spent, it would add to every scenario; the ₹2,889 crore of claims not provided for would subtract. We have not computed either. FY27 will print higher, because of the June quarter's windfall.
The FY26 dividend of ₹8.90, a 4.1% yield on today's price, was paid by 28 October 2026; a buyer today does not get it.
| Scenario | FY29 EPS | P/E | Price, Nov 2029 | Dividends to then | Return a year | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheap LNG wins back Morbi | ₹27.67 | 12x | ₹332 | ₹33.0 | +19.07% | 0.15 |
| Cash returned, re-rated to city-gas peers | ₹20.39 | 15x | ₹306 | ₹99.1 | +23.28% | 0.20 |
| Run-rate holds | ₹21.54 | 10x | ₹215 | ₹28.9 | +4.10% | 0.35 |
| Spread squeeze | ₹16.36 | 8.5x | ₹139 | ₹25.0 | −8.80% | 0.22 |
| Squeeze, and the cash goes to diversification | ₹13.55 | 8x | ₹108 | ₹18.9 | −16.27% | 0.08 |
Weighted, the scenarios are worth ₹267.37 a share in November 2029 with dividends: 7.34% a year from ₹216.18. Most of that comes from the cash-returned scenario, added on 8 November at a judged weight of 0.20. On the four scenarios weighted on 7 November, before it was added, the weighted value was ₹226.40, or 1.55% a year. The weighted value returns 15% a year from ₹175.78; the base case alone needs ₹160.35. The verdict is the same at a 12% or a 17.5% required return.
Each scenario's FY29 earnings are built mainly from these inputs:
| Scenario | City gas: mmscmd × ₹/scm | Trading | Other income | Owners' gap | P/E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cheap LNG wins back Morbi | 12.5 × 5.6 | ₹1,250 cr | ₹700 cr | −₹150 cr | 12 |
| Cash returned, re-rated | 11.0 × 6.0 | ₹1,100 cr | ₹213 cr | −₹250 cr | 15 |
| Run-rate holds | 11.0 × 5.2 | ₹1,100 cr | ₹680 cr | −₹250 cr | 10 |
| Spread squeeze | 10.2 × 4.6 | ₹1,000 cr | ₹600 cr | −₹300 cr | 8.5 |
| Squeeze and diversification | 10.0 × 4.4 | ₹900 cr | ₹520 cr | −₹350 cr | 8 |
Common to every scenario: depreciation ₹650 crore, finance cost ₹40 crore, tax at FY26's 25.58% standalone effective rate, and earnings spread over 93.69 crore shares (net of treasury shares). Exploration, wind and unallocated items net to −₹130 crore (−₹160 crore in the two squeeze cases); FY26 was −₹139 crore. The owners' gap is the amount by which profit to shareholders falls short of the parent's own profit, through the terminal, the power plants and eliminations: ₹280 crore in FY26.
Dividends are 36.3% of standalone earnings (FY26's payout; 30% in the last scenario), and three years' dividends are counted as paid before November 2029, added without reinvestment. In the cash-returned scenario the ₹7,500 crore held at 30 September, less the FY26 dividend, is also paid out as a special dividend of ₹71.04 a share, and its interest, at 7%, leaves other income.
The weights are judgments. The four original scenarios were weighted on 7 November 2026; the cash-returned scenario was added on 8 November, taking its 0.20 from the run-rate (0.10), the squeeze (0.08) and diversification (0.02).
Each scenario's value is a multiple of FY29 earnings plus dividends. Cash the business keeps between now and 2029 enters only through its interest, so in effect it is assumed spent at no return. About ₹900 crore of expected merger tax refunds are not counted, nor ₹2,889 crore of claims not provided for, nor the LNG terminal's rising loan repayments, nor a propane terminal's capex outside the ₹1,000 crore budget.
If the cash is kept, every scenario is understated, the diversification case least. If the claims are lost, every scenario is overstated. We have not computed either.
One input changed at a time, as returns a year from ₹216.18:
| Change | Return a year |
|---|---|
| P/E 8x | −2.4% |
| P/E 12x | +10.0% |
| City-gas margin ₹4.70/scm | +1.7% |
| City-gas margin ₹6.0/scm | +7.9% |
| City-gas volume 10.0 mmscmd | +1.8% |
| City-gas volume 12.0 mmscmd | +6.4% |
| Trading ₹900 crore | +1.7% |
| Trading ₹1,300 crore | +6.5% |
The base case returns 12% a year from ₹173.59, 15% from ₹160.35 and 17.5% from ₹150.33. The weighted value returns 12% from ₹190.29, 15% from ₹175.78 and 17.5% from ₹164.79.
Peers (stockanalysis.com, 6 November 2026 prices): GAIL 9.68x and Petronet 10.26x trailing earnings; the city-gas companies IGL 14.79x and MGL 14.26x forward. IGL's trailing 19.87x is inflated by a 93% fall in its September-quarter profit. On our base case, nothing argues for more than about 10 times, between GAIL and Petronet, while about 40% of profit is a trading spread and interest rates stay high, which we assume.
Brokers. Three sell-side targets published between June and August 2026, two Buys and a Hold, range from ₹275 to ₹454 a share excluding the GSPL Transmission entitlement, all above the price.
Supply of shares. No new issue is in view, since the parent has no loans. But two-thirds of the shares went to former GSPC and GSPL holders, and domestic institutions cut their holding from 24.18% to 21.18% in the September 2026 quarter, about 2.81 crore shares; one large mutual fund went from 5.81% to 3.77% between June and October.
At 30 September 2026 the company held more than ₹7,500 crore of cash. At March 2026, ₹5,018 crore of the parent's ₹5,994 crore sat with a state finance company. Management promises "a concrete plan" by the December quarter that includes a "diversification strategy in the energy business". The state, not the minority holders, will decide.
Two scenarios clear 15%. In the first, the LNG glut management expects brings Morbi back from propane and the shares trade at 12 times earnings; that forecast has already missed once, and management is planning a propane terminal of its own. In the second, the cash is returned to holders and the city-gas margin goes back into its band, and the shares re-rate toward city-gas peers. We give it a weight of 0.20, because management's words on the cash point to diversification and the margin has been below the band for two quarters.
Against the cash sit legacy costs: the subsidiaries lost ₹697 crore in FY26, and ₹2,889 crore of claims, ₹30.8 a share, are not provided for.
The case for the shares rests on two levers.
- The balance sheet. Cash returned to shareholders, about ₹71–80 a share, would reach holders whole instead of being valued at a multiple of its interest, and might narrow the gap between Gujarat Energy's 5.4 times EV/EBITDA and the city-gas peers' 8.8–10.9 times.
- The business. A city-gas margin back in the ₹5.5–6.5 band would add about ₹300 crore of EBITDA a year at today's volume. With both, the trading book might be valued as part of a utility rather than as a spread.
A sum of the parts qualifies the first lever. At the September-quarter margin, with city gas at 8–10 times EBITDA, trading at 4 times, and the subsidiaries' debt and losses counted, the parts are worth ₹208–247 a share: ₹216 prices the current margin rather than a holding-company discount on a recovered business, so the re-rating would have to come from a better margin and a higher multiple on it, not from the cash alone. With the margin back in its band and city gas at 10–12 times, the parts are worth ₹280–390, where the broker targets sit.
The evidence so far runs against it: city-gas earnings have stayed flat while volume rose, the margin has been below the band for two quarters, management's words on the cash plan mention diversification, it is planning a propane terminal outside its capex budget, the subsidiaries carry losses the city-gas peers do not, and domestic institutions sold in the quarter before the cash plan.
Our scenario for this case uses a ₹6.0 margin, the middle of the band, and a special dividend of ₹71.04 a share, the low end of the ₹71–80 range; a buyback is not modelled. What would raise its weight: a plan that returns cash and a December-quarter city-gas margin above ₹5.5. What would lower it: a plan to deploy the cash outside gas, or a third quarter below the band.
- Losses in FY26: the LNG terminal company ₹413 crore, the Pipavav power plant ₹196 crore, the other power company ₹87 crore. The terminal ran at about 17% utilisation in FY26 (35–38% in May–July 2026); the power plants at about 1% and 6%.
- The terminal's loan from the state finance company is at 7%, with repayments rising from 2.25% of the loan in FY27 to 22.25% in FY34.
- Claims not provided for: ₹1,688.66 crore of income tax, with the government's appeal pending in the Supreme Court, and more than ₹1,200 crore claimed by Vedanta. The auditor draws attention to both.
- Tax: current tax is near zero while ₹1,892 crore of carried-in losses last, and about ₹900 crore of merger tax refunds are expected, at least a year away.
- Dividends follow the state government's guidelines: 36.3% of standalone profit in FY26, about 11% in FY22.
The cheapest test is the September-quarter results filing with its segment note, which we had not read, and the call transcript once filed: public documents, a few hours' reading. They should say whether the margin fall is mix or squeeze, whether management keeps its band, what Morbi's volume was, and what the cash plan will be. They can move weight between the run-rate and squeeze cases, and raise or lower the cash-returned case. They cannot bring the weighted value to 15% a year at ₹216.
Then the December-quarter results, due by mid-February 2027, score the scenarios directly.
| What the company will report | Due | Flat-franchise model (base, glut) | Squeeze model | Cash-returned case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| City-gas plus trading EBITDA, December 2026 quarter | 15 Feb 2027 | ₹760–950 cr | ₹560–740 cr | as the flat-franchise model |
| City-gas EBITDA per scm, December 2026 quarter | 15 Feb 2027 | ₹4.80–5.80 | ₹4.00–4.70 | ₹5.50 or more |
| Cash returned by buyback or special dividend, announced by then | 15 Feb 2027 | No: kept | No: deployed, partly outside gas | Yes |
| City-gas volume, FY27 | 31 May 2027 | 10.80–11.60 mmscmd | 10.00–10.70 | as the flat-franchise model |
| Trading EBITDA, FY27 | 31 May 2027 | ₹1,650–1,950 cr | ₹1,350–1,640 cr | as the flat-franchise model |
| Consolidated EPS, FY28, audited | 31 May 2028 | ₹20.00–25.00 | ₹13.50–17.50 | as the flat-franchise model |
The due dates are ours, set from the company's calendar. These assume the internal transfer price and the segment reporting stay as they are, no new supply shock (which would lift trading in every case) and no tax change on natural gas. One quarter's miss decides nothing on its own.
- Combined city-gas and trading EBITDA below ₹650 crore, the September 2025 quarter's level, for two consecutive quarters without a supply shock.
- City-gas EBITDA below ₹420 crore a quarter for two consecutive quarters while volume stays above 10 million scm a day.
- Trading below ₹2.3 per scm sourced for two consecutive quarters.
- Profit to shareholders more than ₹100 crore a quarter below the parent's own profit for two consecutive quarters. The September 2026 quarter was one such quarter, about ₹142 crore below: about ₹570 crore a year if it held, against the ₹250 crore the base case assumes. Whether it is a new level, and where in the subsidiaries it fell, is not known.
- The September 2026 quarter's own filings: the consolidated figures here are a data provider's tabulation, the quarter's profit to shareholders is inferred from earnings per share, and the call transcript was not yet filed.
- Whether the margin band and the ₹1,100 crore trading figure still stand, and what that figure measures.
- Morbi's volume and margin in the September quarter.
- The transfer price between trading and city gas, and whether it changed on 1 May 2026.
- The cash plan, and whether the ₹7,500 crore at 30 September is before or after the ₹835 crore dividend.
- Whether the subsidiaries' ₹3,060 crore of debt, mainly the LNG terminal's, has recourse to the parent.
- Whether the June 2026 quarter's figures include the amalgamated businesses for the whole quarter.
- ADNOC's price formula, and who supplies the other 0.4 million tonnes a year.
- How the tax appeal and the Vedanta claim end, and the regulator's common-carrier decision.
- Dividend policy beyond the state government's guidelines.
- What drove the 3.8% fall in the share price on 6 November, the day after the results.
Company documents: annual reports for FY2025 and FY2026; investor presentations of August and November 2025 and January, June, August and November 2026; earnings-call transcripts of August and November 2025 and January, June and August 2026. Prices: NSE closes of 5 and 6 November 2026. Consolidated September-quarter figures and shareholding: Screener.in. Peer multiples: stockanalysis.com, 6 November 2026. APM allocation cuts and exclusivity: press reports. Broker targets are summarised without naming the brokers.
Where sources disagreed we relied on the audited accounts over data providers' tabulations, and on the restated FY25 figures over earlier filings. Figures marked as ours are our arithmetic on these documents.